Sherlock Holmes A game of Shadows Plot holes

Minor Plot hole: A bomb explodes in a Hotel leaving no survivors. The bomb is so strong that all the glass windows exploded on impact. Somehow, Holmes and Watson are able to forensic the shit out of the Hotel room to understand that the bomb was a cover operation to hide a sniper assassination that happened a few seconds before the bomb exploded.

How did they find out? Oh. Real simple. You see, they found a bullet hole in a glass window on the right of….Wait. Something sounds stupid. Could it be the fact that….. all windows shattered to dust after the massive explosion and that there would be no way to spot a bullet hole in a glass that doesn’t exist anymore? No. Not that. I know what sounds stupid! Why blow a bomb to kill everyone in a room as a cover-up operation for an assassination that would kill the same man?The cover-up operation was way more effective alone.

Major Plot hole: There is pretty much no way Sherlock Holmes could have survived his jump/fall at the end.  I’m not even going into the “hypothermia-related” reason why this should be the last Sherlock Holmes with Robert Downey.  But try jumping off a mountainside and see how that works out for you, you can even take all the scuba gear you want…..uh on second thought movieplotholes would not appreciate getting a bunch of assisted suicide charges on record so please dont try it.  But plenty of people have already tried and didn’t live to tell the tale because they know the formula; a jump off a very tall structure equals certain death, EVEN if they are jumping into water.

Do bridge suicides ring a bell? So who cares if he had that handy little oxygen to help him breathe? He would still have to survive the fall for it to even be useful, which it probably would not have been because as you may or may not know dead people don’t really need oxygen. The ONLY way we could even REMOTELY consider the fact that he wasn’t fish food would be if he somehow didn’t fall the entire way. Which is anything but implied when he ominously places his ‘’oxygen tank’’ on Watson’s desk at the end.  (by G. Osae)

Plot contrivance: Holmes meets his match in this movie. An individual at least as brilliant as him: Professor James Moriarty. But he has his own limitations – he can’t remember everything. Well, he can play chess from a mental image in his head, but somehow, his god-like intellect can’t remember all his war-profit operations by heart and he thus needs to write a few things down in a personal notebook. Fair enough, we can let this one slip.

Moriarty is later defeated by Holmes mainly because he was able to switch his notebook with a fake, and send the original one to the police in order to stop Moriarty’s war plans. So it means Sherlock Holmes made an incredibly huge gamble. He had to assume 4 important things:

  1. He assumed that Moriarty’s brutal non-PETA approved fish-torture would not kill him.
  2. He assumed Moriarty would keep his notebook on himself during the operation like any sophisticated madman with a giant hook.
  3. He assumed his sleight of hand chest molestation with his newly tortured body would work with finesse without no one noticing.
  4. He assumed that Moriarty would never look at his notebook again until Holmes would challenge him to do so a few days later.

If any of those 4 assumptions on his super intelligent nemesis failed to become reality– Holmes would have lost. And yet somehow he won!

Plot contrivance: Sherlock Holmes disguises himself as the most scary-looking shemale ever seen inside a non-Thai train and no one, not even the military officers who talk directly to him, realize he is a man. Which gives a tone of complete farce and comedy to a movie that takes itself very seriously – hence destroying all the future attempts to make the audience believe in the seriousness of the plot.